Looking for info or opinions on the newer Id sizing 30/35 mm . If people have any opinions or valid points please share .Depends on the tyre and what rim width the designer had in mind. Minions and rollers don't seem to play well above 25mm or so internal width ( source mtbr posters in downhill)
But generally your question is a can of worms with opinion only as your answers
Ok, best summary I can give you from this topic on mtbr is there are 2 tyre designers on mtbr, one for specialized and one ex maxxis designer, and both say their designs are for commonly used rims at the time of design - so that generally is around 24, 25mm for a downhill tyre and 21mm for xc, am etc. One of those designers ( the ex maxxis guy) says advantages to wider IDs stops at around 27mm ( is that the wide lightening width perhaps?). This obviously disagrees with ibis and derby who are trail blazing wider is better.Looking for info or opinions on the newer Id sizing 30/35 mm . If people have any opinions or valid points please share .
A friend has the 40 mm /35 mm ID rim running a2.4 Minion DHR2 , what i did notice was how much more side wall was exposed . Im tossing up between rims , fat carbons or alloys around the 27 id mark . So Im trying to work out pro`s and cons . While were having a chat , what do you think about rims . carbon v alloy etc .Ok, best summary I can give you from this topic on mtbr is there are 2 tyre designers on mtbr, one for specialized and one ex maxxis designer, and both say their designs are for commonly used rims at the time of design - so that generally is around 24, 25mm for a downhill tyre and 21mm for xc, am etc. One of those designers ( the ex maxxis guy) says advantages to wider IDs stops at around 27mm ( is that the wide lightening width perhaps?). This obviously disagrees with ibis and derby who are trail blazing wider is better.
Point 2 - how the tyre changes shape when you look at it bears no relationship to how it acts on the contact patch.
Wider rims do seem to hold the tyre better and lessen the incidence of burping, so you can run a lower pressure than previous. HOWEVER, this now increases the chance of rim strike, which for alloy rims is not such a big issue, but tends to crack a lot of the carbon ones. So if you need higher pressure because of burping on corners but never rim strike, they are an advantage.
That's my summary of the situation anyway