Iran: so how f***ed are we all?

You were hoping for the deaths of many US forces and fuel going to $5/litre, which reads to me like a major escalation of what's going on currently.

Might help if you expand on your thinking and explain how you think this situation might come about.
Nah its just an opinion based on theories you dont accept.
 
What a cop out.

I can't tell you if I accept or disagree with your theories if you don't explain them in at least some detail.
Cop out! My theory is that USA likes wars that are elsewhere, never close to home soil { whereas its can be in Europe's back yard,} and they can display their technological might.
They like the Russians are nationalistic war mongers
A major technological glitch that embarrases them and it would need to kill some troops would bring the reality home to USA people .
Maybe then there would be pressure to end it.
Otherwise most recent wars have been attrition ,with USA successful in none of them and eventually troops are sent home achieving nothing except spending about 1 trillion dollars and probably a million enemy and civilian deaths since 2000 .
End of converstaion thanks Tubbsy.
 
End of converstaion thanks Tubbsy.
No need to chuck a tanty about it.
Yes I thought i would stir things up.I can take the heat.

I don't disagree with your potted history of American war efforts, but you gave no indication earlier whether you hoped for a post-WW2 global reset or a post-Vietnam crisis in American politics as a solution to this Iran situation.

At the moment there's little chance of American troop losses in the conflict unless there is a huge escalation with the Americans sending troops in to the front line and Israel escalating alongside them, hence my reference to WW3. Not sure what technological glitch might achieve this either, hence the questions...

I still don't see how your hope for troops to die and fuel to become punishingly expensive is somehow the best case long-term scenario. Or even a likely one.

Just sounds to me like you wanted to say something dramatic rather than actually giving it serious thought.
 
Cop out! My theory is that USA likes wars that are elsewhere, never close to home soil { whereas its can be in Europe's back yard,} and they can display their technological might.

That's common for many countries though. The Spanish Civil War and the current war in Ukraine are case studies of this. Every major-to-middle power that can (US, UK, Germany, China, DPRK, Sweden, Iran, etc.) is sending weapons to Ukraine to battle test them and gather data for further development. They are also engaging to try and weaken their adversary, even if by just chewing up resources and complicating their domestic politics. The Spanish civil war was the same with the Soviets, Germans, etc. all testing their new aircraft and bombs in the lead up to WW2. The US is no different than any other power, in this respect.
A major technological glitch that embarrases them and it would need to kill some troops would bring the reality home to USA people .
Maybe then there would be pressure to end it.
Otherwise most recent wars have been attrition ,with USA successful in none of them and eventually troops are sent home achieving nothing except spending about 1 trillion dollars and probably a million enemy and civilian deaths since 2000 .
Aren't these two points contradictory? You've said that a US fuck-up that kills a lot of Americans would likely end the war. Then you go on to say that the US has a long history of fuck-ups with lots of deaths, but they end up being wars of attrition. That means they DON'T end because of the fuck ups and deaths. Aren't you defeating your own argument here yourself?
 
No not really I think I have made a simple argument.
A single technical glitch that potentially killed or maimed thousands of US personnel wouldn't end one of their military adventures unless said glitch substantially hindered their capability (financially and resource capacity wise) to prosecute whatever adventure they are participating in.

The actual lives lost would be a tragedy but not especially impactful in a nation of hundreds of millions of people with a long cultural history of honouring their veterans in a thoughts and prayers kind of way.
 
A single technical glitch that potentially killed or maimed thousands of US personnel wouldn't end one of their military adventures unless said glitch substantially hindered their capability (financially and resource capacity wise) to prosecute whatever adventure they are participating in.

The actual lives lost would be a tragedy but not especially impactful in a nation of hundreds of millions of people with a long cultural history of honouring their veterans in a thoughts and prayers kind of way.
Iraq war 2003-2011 would be a case in point.

Others might argue Afghanistan and Vietnam as well.
 
Back
Top