Electric Vehicles etc

Stredda

Runs naked through virgin scrub
Nissan Leaf was a big missed opportunity, they could have owned the market by now, but they still only make one very ordinary BEV and have been outrun for years by Tesla and now BYD.



Dude didn't have comp insurance was the actual problem there, what if the debris sent him off the road and wrote the entire car off? Suck shit is what!

Let's say we let anyone repair a high voltage battery pack however they wanted, and then the car catches fire because they didn't repair to the same integrity as the OEM and the battery overheated, taking a carpark full of cars and a couple of buildings with it. All 'cos someone didn't insure their car properly. No manufacturer wants that to happen. So then they would have to certify anyone doing repairs, especially when it is repairing the pack, cos that shit can kill you. I would be surprised if any manufacturer on the face of the earth would be any different to Tesla in this case.
You can still have certified EV repairers do the job, just as you have qualified mechanic work on your car. I don't like the way a lot of things are going (not just EVs) where you can't repair a product. It's made in a way to discourage repair, in favour of replacement.
 

Scotty T

Walks the walk
Truth hurts. :p
Anyone remeber the Ford Taurus? They came in a distinct maroon colour and my dad always said they looked like a half sucked Throatie.

The Teslas and that new Hyundai, and some other modern EV's suffer from it, they called it "aerodynamics" and it's quite a new thing in the auto industry to achieve maximum "aerodynamic efficiency" so as not to "waste energy" like every other car ever did, except maybe the Taurus. The mind boggles ;)
 

Scotty T

Walks the walk
You can still have certified EV repairers do the job, just as you have qualified mechanic work on your car. I don't like the way a lot of things are going (not just EVs) where you can't repair a product. It's made in a way to discourage repair, in favour of replacement.
100%, it's across every industry and it does really suck. Despite a certified EV repairer, some repairs, like a cooling tube into a HV pack, might still be deemed not safe to cobble a repair together and still warranty the car.
 

Haakon

Keeps on digging
Renault/Nissan had a huuuge first mover advantage and could easily have been where Tesla is now. Even before the Leaf Renault had an electric Fluence and Renault for a while there looked like being a real innovator.

Coulda woulda shoulda…
 

Stredda

Runs naked through virgin scrub
100%, it's across every industry and it does really suck. Despite a certified EV repairer, some repairs, like a cooling tube into a HV pack, might still be deemed not safe to cobble a repair together and still warranty the car.
That's where manufacturers need to step up and provide service parts that like that coolant tube would be easy to replace and not replace a whole perfectly serviceable battery pack. Such a wasteful process. :(
There is whole niche aftermarket industry that's starting to gain momentum that are providing parts to repair EVs where the OME won't support it. You can already see it with the Nissan Leaf. I have noticed it with Ebikes, as most motors aren't "serviceable" according to the manufacturers, but they really are, and instead of just binning the motor, aftermarket companies are now making service kits or providing the service of rebuilding them.
 

beeb

Dr. Beebenson, PhD HA, ST, Offset (hons)
...that new Hyundai...
I actually don't mind it. For starters it doesn't look like it's made of Lego like the other Hyundai, it reminds me more of a modern Citroen DS. Though like the DS they decided to put oddly ugly tail-lights on an otherwise decent looking car.
 

dancaseyimages

Mountain bike pornographer
You can still have certified EV repairers do the job, just as you have qualified mechanic work on your car. I don't like the way a lot of things are going (not just EVs) where you can't repair a product. It's made in a way to discourage repair, in favour of replacement.
That was never my favourite part once I was qualified ticking off the trades assistants work, I know they are usually pretty skilled just without the cert but it's still a risk, it takes a while to get a trades assistant up to spec and I know dealerships its usually 4 to 1 (mechanic/trades assistant) or 3 to 1 for the more expensive ones but I guess that ratio may change with electric cars and more of a chance of something happening.
 

dancaseyimages

Mountain bike pornographer
That's where manufacturers need to step up and provide service parts that like that coolant tube would be easy to replace and not replace a whole perfectly serviceable battery pack. Such a wasteful process. :(
There is whole niche aftermarket industry that's starting to gain momentum that are providing parts to repair EVs where the OME won't support it. You can already see it with the Nissan Leaf. I have noticed it with Ebikes, as most motors aren't "serviceable" according to the manufacturers, but they really are, and instead of just binning the motor, aftermarket companies are now making service kits or providing the service of rebuilding them.
I agree with this very much.
Whilst the right to repair has made some things very obsolete and obscure to use especially in Australia.
I looked into the Fairphone a while ago, there was limitations on the networks it could work with and a bit of a hacky solution for use in Australia.
Fairphone - Wikipedia

And then theres the modular laptops (Which I am looking at but will await some tech conferences where I can see them/ask questions of real world users before taking the dip)
Framework | Framework Laptop 16 pre-orders are now open

My last laptop a Dell XPS, is so thin and the casing is just wedged together that when 'repaired' where the whole motherboard was replaced due to a dying HDD, ended up slightly bent. Which meant returning for a new unit, the older Macbooks were easy to open up but reading the Verge article (linked below) sounds like its quite an effort now with the Apple products too.
The right-to-repair movement is just getting started - The Verge

I did have a quick google last night and there is lots of Nissan Leaf parts / things you can do at home without to many specialized tools like Brakes etc but the Tesla's I guess you just buy in knowing that you need a Texpert to do all the jobs. Like the Apple Genuis bar.
 

Haakon

Keeps on digging
Teslas should be ok for normal diy stuff like brakes and suspension and trim etc etc. A motor swap might be an issue, depends on they’re coded to the car and need to be enabled - not sure if there are OBD readers that will talk to all functions and configurations in Tesla
 

ozzybmx

Not a tree-hugging earth muffin
Renault/Nissan had a huuuge first mover advantage and could easily have been where Tesla is now. Even before the Leaf Renault had an electric Fluence and Renault for a while there looked like being a real innovator.

Coulda woulda shoulda…
Coulda said that about Toyota with the Prius.

Did they recognise the popularity and purposely not go full EV for some reason. Every taxi in this city is a Toyo Hybrid something. Why did they stop at Hybrid.
 
Last edited:

Asininedrivel

caviar connoisseur
Anyone remeber the Ford Taurus? They came in a distinct maroon colour and my dad always said they looked like a half sucked Throatie.

The Teslas and that new Hyundai, and some other modern EV's suffer from it, they called it "aerodynamics" and it's quite a new thing in the auto industry to achieve maximum "aerodynamic efficiency" so as not to "waste energy" like every other car ever did, except maybe the Taurus. The mind boggles ;)
What are you on about? Car manufacturers have been obsessed with aerodynamic efficiency since forever, they even used drag coefficiency figures as a selling point for cars in the 1980s (yes really).

The Model Y might have an annoyingly low drag coefficiency of 0.23, but that's still only 0.3 better than a 1989 Holden Calibra.
 

Scotty T

Walks the walk
C'mon dude the throatie effect is real, your link proves it! :D

I was kinda taking the piss, but also commenting on other SUV's the size of the Y which are bricks on wheels comparitively. The trend has gone not too far (surely the massive size of the newer cars negate some of the better aerodynamics) since the Calibra, until EV's started to try and fix range anxiety.
 

Dales Cannon

Too old for this shit
Staff member
What are you on about? Car manufacturers have been obsessed with aerodynamic efficiency since forever, they even used drag coefficiency figures as a selling point for cars in the 1980s (yes really).

The Model Y might have an annoyingly low drag coefficiency of 0.23, but that's still only 0.3 better than a 1989 Holden Calibra.
cDA is the key factor and it will be low. Interesting that Musk has so many dogs to model from.
 

Haakon

Keeps on digging
I once had an unhealthy urge to buy a Calibra… In awd form they were pretty decent. Luckily I couldn’t find a decent one and my short attention span moved on…
 
Top