If the 2012 Boxxer has 74mm Post Mounts and the brake caliper is made to fit on 74mm Post Mounts why would a 51mm IS adapter be needed.
'Ezkaton' asking a 'similar' question has confused the answers, 'A-Listers Only' doesn't need a 51mm IS adapter, a 74mm PM adapter is needed.
A 2012 Boxxer needs the following adapters for 200/203mm rotors.
200mm:
http://www.artscyclery.com/Avid_Pos...t_200_Front___180_Rear/descpage-AVAP200K.html
203mm:
http://www.artscyclery.com/Shimano_Disc_Adapter_Front_203mm_Post_to_Post/descpage-1122539.html
http://www.artscyclery.com/Magura_Post_Mount_6_Disc_Brake_Adapter_203_Rotor/descpage-MGDAR6203.html
http://www.artscyclery.com/Formula_Disc_Brake_Adapter_PM6-_203mm/descpage-FRRAKFPM03.html
Fox 40's have the IS brake mounts set at 203mm specs not 160mm specs, to use a PM caliper on a Fox 40 with a 203mm rotor you'd need to use a 160mm PM to IS adapter as it doesn't increase the size of the IS mounts.
Avid's Front 160mm / Rear 140mm PM to IS adapter is now called a 0mm adapter because it keeps the size of the IS mounts.
With a 203mm PM to IS adapter on a Fox 40 with 203mm IS mounts you'd need to use a 240mm rotor.